Compost and Soil Amendments


Compost and Soil Amendments

Using compost is a fantastic way to supply your plants with the nutrients they need to grow to their fullest potential. Compost can be used in the family garden to grow fruits and vegetables, potted plants to improve the life of beloved flowers, and also in your landscape beds to increase the longevity of plants and shrubs.
Compost feedstocks are created from decomposed animal waste, bedding, grass clippings, leaves, and plant waste. Although compost cannot be made instantly at McCarty Mulch, we allow our compost to sit for many months before it is sold. This allows the compost to decompose slowly along with regular rotation intervals, and proper moisture content, which allows our compost to mature properly and evenly. When the compost is finished it is then screen to a fine, black, texture. We offer three distinct products of our garden compost at McCarty Mulch, so you can be sure that you’ll find exactly what you need.

We’ll discuss each to determine which fits your needs best.

Planter’s Mix

McCarty Mulch’s Planter’s Mix is a blend of pulverized topsoil, garden compost and a small amount of sand and mulch. These ingredients create a perfect blend for your new flower beds or the family garden. Planter’s Mix will provide you with the base that you need to ensure that your plants are getting the nutrients that they need to thrive.

Garden Compost

Our Garden Compost is exactly what the title says. It is McCarty’s purest form of compost. A blend of farmyard manure, straw, and sawdust is combined and left to sit and age for over 18 months. This produces a fine, black soil that adds organic matter, nutrients, nitrogen, and oxygen to anything planted within it. Not only that, but our garden compost is great at retaining moisture, making it a perfect amendment to topsoil or Planter’s Mix to create the perfect environment for your potted plants or garden.


The last of McCarty’s three forms of compost is our Ultra Soil. The most popular of them all, Ultra Soil is a blend of reed sedge-based peat moss and rich, black Northern Indiana topsoil. This high-quality soil offers superior water and nutrient retention and helps to keep your plants oxidized and healthy, allowing for phenomenal growth. Ultra-Soil is also rich and humus and nitrogen, giving your plants the natural chemicals necessary to grow.

compost and garden

6 Benefits of Using Compost in Your Garden

Compost is king. If you could only add one amendment to your garden, it would most certainly be compost. There are many other soil amendments used to solve specific issues, such as:

  • Add sulfur or lime to adjust the pH levels of your soil.
  • Add sand to heavy clay soil to make it more workable and adjust water drainage.
  • Add peat moss to sandy soil to increase water retention.
  • Add fertilizer to increase nutrients for your plants.

Or…you can just add compost to your soil and do all of these. Compost is like the full body workout for your garden. Use a specialized amendment if you have a prominent problem. Otherwise, compost is the least expensive yet most effective way to keep your garden strong and healthy.

Here are the nine most obvious benefits:

1. Compost Improves Soil Structure

Adding compost improves drainage in clay soils and increases water retention in sandy soils enhancing the structure of both.

Soil structure is the foundation for any healthy garden. In good soil, different materials combine, forming aggregates which are small, irregularly shaped particles that clump together. This clumping creates spaces and channels in the soil which allows air circulation and water drainage.

These channels are also easy paths for plant roots to follow. Plants in loose, crumbly soil typically develop deeper root systems than plants in heavy soils making it more likely your plants can reach nutrients and water held deeper in the dirt.

Neither sand nor clay absorbs water well. Water drains too fast between the large particles found in sand, and it gets trapped by the tiny particles found in clay. The organic material in compost absorbs water far better than sand but is more willing to release it than clay.

2. Compost Adds (some) Nutrients

Despite many that say compost is not a fertilizer, no one can say that it doesn’t contain some nutrients.

Mature compost can contain small amounts of a few primary nutrients:

Roughly 0.6.-0.9% phosphorus, 0.2-0.5% potassium, and 1-2% nitrogen, It can also include low levels of secondary nutrients such as calcium, magnesium, and sulfur.

More notably, it provides essential micronutrients like copper, zinc, iron, and manganese which are crucial, in minute quantities, to growing healthy plants and are often missing in synthetic fertilizers.

3. Compost Adds and Attracts Beneficial Microbes

“Think of composting as the act of growing microorganisms.” – Compost Fundamentals, Washington State University.

You may have heard the term “beneficial microbes;” it isn’t just a gardening buzz-word. The fact that compost plays host to a plethora of living creatures and plays a large part in nurturing others is what sets it apart from the other soil amendments. The smallest of these creatures play perhaps the most significant roles.

Micro-organisms improve soil-structure because they help the soil to aggregate. The hyphae of some fungi for example and actinomycetes that thrive in organic soils also contribute to soil aggregation. Because coconut coir and peat moss and are sterile materials, they don’t provide these benefits to the soil.

Some microbes help reduce and even prevent plant diseases while yet others can establish the mycorrhizal fungi which allow plant roots access to nutrients below the reach of their roots.

4. Compost Reduces Plant Diseases

Specific soil bacteria and various beneficial fungi sustained by compost help prevent an extensive range of plant diseases reducing the need for fungicides (for the bad fungi) and other chemicals, many of which can be toxic to varying degrees to animals, humans, and the beneficial microbes discussed previously.

Compost is used to combat avocado root-rot in both California and Brazil, and it is reported to have potential in fighting tomato diseases.

A major British review identified four different ways microbes are currently believed to fight soil-borne diseases. Beneficial microbes can:

  • Parasitize pathogens
  • Activate disease-resistant genes in plants
  • Out-compete other organisms for nutrients
  • Produce antibiotics

5. Nourishes Larger Soil Organisms

Worms, insects, and other small creatures benefit from compost and in turn, will improve soil structure by aerating as they move through it. They are a significant part of the complex soil ecosystem that helps make plant life possible. Earthworms not only turn the soil, but their excrement is some of the best compost your soil can have, and in the end, they contribute to the organic matter in the soil when they die.

6. Compost Helps Balance pH

The pH level of soil affects a plant’s ability to access nutrients as it changes the chemical structure of those nutrients into forms that are unusable or that the roots cannot absorb.

Like its ability to improve both sandy and clay soils, compost can also balance pH levels in either direction. It can make acidic soil more alkaline and alkaline soil more acidic. This is kind of strange because, unlike most pH amendments, the pH of compost practically neutral.

Compost can balance pH because it boosts something called the cation exchange capacity (CEC) of the soil. The CEC index is, basically, the measure of how well soil retains nutrients and how available those nutrients are to the plants. A low CEC means that soil has a lower capacity for nutrient retention, (fertilizers are more quickly leached away). A higher CEC (anything over 50) means a greater capacity for nutrient retention, (fertilizers remain usable for longer).

CEC says nothing about the soil’s nutrient content. Only how well soil can retain the nutrients it has. Also, CEC is not the only factor that impacts the availability of nutrients to the plants. We’ve briefly discussed two other factors, both pH and micro-organisms, which play a significant role in the availability of nutrients (and are also beneficially affected by the addition of compost).

So, Why Is Compost King Exactly?

The three major factors of soil health, chemical, physical, and biological, interact in complex ways. Compost is unique in that it can affect all three factors, and how they interact in positive ways.

Increasing the organic material, including humus, in your soil:

  • raises the CEC index, (thus stabilizing pH)
  • adds and attracts beneficial microbes, insects, and worms
  • improves the drainage problems of both sandy and clay soils.

Compost creates the ideal environment for improving soil structure and its ability to retain nutrients and improves their availability to your plants.

If you are ready to start adding compost to your soil, our garden compost is an optimal mix of organic materials, is matured for a minimum of 18 months, and ready to go to work for your plants.



wooden crate of fresh garden vegetables

Mulch or Compost for your Vegetable Garden?

If you’re an avid gardener, then you know nutrient deficiency in soil limits plant growth and crop yield. Using mulch or compost improves crop growth, but is using one better than the other? McCarty Mulch and Stone can help you decide which organic materials harvest the most crops for your gardening needs.

Mulch or Compost for my Vegetables?

Garden compost: composed of fine materials and controls soil temperatures.

Adding nutrients to soil is a must, and compost is a super food for plants. Although worms and other creatures burrow through the soil to mix it, nutrients in compost release slowly as it decomposes into organic matter.

Where can you get compost? Gather old newspaper shreddings and grass clippings to make homemade compost, or save time and visit your local landscape retailer for rich organic garden compost. For example, horse and cow manure mixed with straw and sawdust aged over months when blended correctly can add organic matter to the most clay-packed soils. The mixture enhances growth to produce beautiful flowers and robust vegetation.

Garden mulch: a smokescreen for your soil.

Layers of mulch retain moisture, protect crops from weeds and gives your home curb appeal.  Mulch can contain a bark, recycled wood, pine needles or stone depending on your preferences and the condition of your yard’s soil.

Mulch releases a low percentage of nutrients; its main purpose is to suppress weed growth and retain water in the soil. Put a fresh layer of mulch on your soil, but avoid covering plant stems and branches. If you do, then bugs and diseases will use the covered area as a habitat. Therefore, leave a few inches of space around the plants. Without mulch, weeds can spiral out of control making it difficult for you to remove without mangling plant stems.

How to decide

It may come down to preference. Compost is natural and provides more nutrients than mulch but generally is not as aesthetically pleasing. And if you want aesthetics, mulch is multichromatic and creates an attractive look. Both retain water, prevent disease and control temperatures in the soil as well as:

  • Reduce foliage and fruit disease
  • Control pests
  • Reduce Weeds
  • Retain Moisture
  • Preserve environmental quality for decades

Whatever your preference, we’ll help you decide on the best mulch or compost materials that meet your gardening needs. You deserve the best quality and we guarantee you’ll be satisfied when you leave. Give us a call today!